Substitutionary Atonement: Jesus Died to Change Us, not God

This is something I wrote in a Facebook comment. I would like to hold on to it, and I hope it helps you understand Romans and the whole New Testament.

There is a clear origin in St. Anselm for the idea that Jesus had to die in order for the Father to forgive sin. (In other words, the origin of that doctrine is not the apostles, but from a Roman Catholic who lived in the 11th century.) Before that, as a reader of the church fathers, I do not think that doctrine existed. How could it? God forgave sin all through the Old Testament, and he is continually described as a merciful God. King David even said that God did not want sacrifice but repentance! (Ps. 51:16-17). And again, “to obey is better than sacrifice” (1 Sam. 15:22).

Instead, Jesus died to free us from slavery to sin. God was already merciful. Look at his description of the judgment in Ezek. 18:20-30. Even in the Old Testament, a person who repented and did righteousness could be forgiven and receive life. The problem is that so few of us actually lived righteously. That is Paul’s point in Romans 3 and Romans 7. The problem is us, and the problem is so bad that even a good, perfect, and holy law could not fix us (Rom. 7; Gal. 3:21). But what the Law could not do, God did by sending his Son in the likeness of sinful flesh as an offering for sin (Rom. 8:3). The law could not make us righteous, but the sacrifice of Jesus can make us righteous. Thus, when the Gentiles first believed, the Jewish Christians in Jerusalem remarked, “So God has granted repentance leading to life to the Gentiles as well” (Acts 11:18).

The gift of the atonement, and even of grace, is the power to live righteously and thus receive the ongoing mercy of God, which was always available even under the Old Testament (Ex. 34:6-7). Jesus did not die to change God or cause God to be free to give mercy. Jesus died for us! We were the problem, not God. Look at the description of the atonement in Titus 2:11-14, which describes both grace and the purpose of Jesus’ death. The gift of grace is that sin no longer has power over us (Rom. 6:14).

That is why even after Jesus died for us, Paul says three times that the unrighteous will not inherit God’s kingdom (1 Cor. 6:9-11; Gal. 5:19-21; Eph. 5:5). Two of those times, he says not to be deceived about that (1 Cor. 6:9; Eph. 5:6), and the other time he tells the Galatians he has been saying this repeatedly (Gal. 5:21). John tells us not to be deceived that it is only those who are practicing righteousness who have the imputed righteousness of God (1 Jn. 3:7). Yet, we have been deceived about all these things that the apostles warned us not to be deceived about. Why? Because we think Jesus died to change God rather than dying to change us.

About Paul Pavao

I am married, the father of six, and currently the grandfather of two. I run a business, live in a Christian community, teach, and I am learning to disciple others better than I have ever been able to before. I believe God has gifted me to restore proper foundations to the Christian faith. In order to ensure that I do not become a heretic, I read the early church fathers from the second and third centuries. They were around when all the churches founded by the apostles were in unity. I also try to stay honest and open. I argue and discuss these foundational doctrines with others to make sure my teaching really lines up with Scripture. I am encouraged by the fact that the several missionaries and pastors that I know well and admire as holy men love the things I teach. I hope you will be encouraged too. I am indeed tearing up old foundations created by tradition in order to re-establish the foundations found in Scripture and lived on by the churches during their 300 years of unity.
This entry was posted in Dealing with Scripture Honestly, Evangelicals and tagged , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

4 Responses to Substitutionary Atonement: Jesus Died to Change Us, not God

  1. Paul my Brother In Christ Jesus if you made the correction it still is in error. Paragraph # 4 Line #2 take out the word ‘with” and put “which”. have a Grace Empowered Day.

  2. Paul, great article. however you have a typo error on paragraph # 4 line # 2. … mercy of God “with” always available. Should be …. mercy of God “was” always available. Love from you LDS Brother In Christ Jesus Kal – El Anakin Skywalker. The Atonement It Is The Central Doctrine, Washing My Garment/Robe In His Blood In His Eternal Debt/Grace. He Died To Make Man Holy – It’s not just 6 words to a song, They Have Eternal Meaning.

Leave a Reply to Kal-EL Anakin Skywalker Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.