I am slowly–very slowly–building a curriculum for discipleship. I wrote a post about 3 weeks ago on the skeleton of that curriculum: 1. Becoming a Christian; 2. Living like a Christian; and 3. Staying a Christian.
It is certain that if I want to write about becoming a Christian, then I must include the “message of the first things of Christ” mentioned in Hebrews 6:1-2. Most translations use something akin to the King James’ “elementary principles of Christ.” My rendering is more literal, though the “message of the first things of Christ” is equivalent to “elementary principles of Christ.”
The writer of Hebrews, possibly Paul but hotly debated, gives us six teachings that are the “first things” or “elementary principles” of Christ:
- Repentance from dead works
- Faith towards God
- Teaching of baptisms
- Laying on of hands
- Resurrection of the dead
- Eternal judgment
Meyer’s New Testament Commentary tells me that these are doublets. Repentance from dead works goes with faith towards God; the teaching of baptisms goes with the laying on of hands; and the resurrection of the dead goes with eternal judgment.
On the issues of Greek grammar structure, Meyer is light years ahead of me. I’m a beginner, and he is an expert. I am going to simply believe him. It seems obvious that repentance and faith go together and that resurrection and judgment go together. Once he said that baptisms, plural, and the laying on of hands were together, that link seemed obvious to me as well. I’ll explain that link below.
If I were teaching a class, I would explain these doublets as quickly as possible, then leave the juicy (=fun) details to a discussion that would consume most of the class time. Let’s do this blog post that way.
Repentance from Dead Works and Faith Towards God
As I said, this connection is obvious. Jesus began his preaching ministry with, “The time is fulfilled, and God’s Kingdom is at hand! Repent, and believe in the Gospel” (Mark 1:15).
Not so obvious is what dead works are. “Dead works” is only used twice in the New Testament, both times in Hebrews. The other is Hebrews 9:14:
… how much more will the blood of Christ, who through the eternal Spirit offered himself without defect to God, cleanse your conscience from dead works to serve the living God?
Meyers gives a simple definition of dead works: dead works are works that do you no good (“in themselves vain and fruitless”). Paul’s goal in Romans is to convince Jews (and teach Gentiles) that it is more powerful to believe in God through Jesus Christ than to try to do good deeds by your own power in obedience to the law. Faith in God brings favor and the Holy Spirit which transform and empower you to do overcome sin and do good, to obey the Spirit and put to death the deeds of the body (e.g., Romans 6:7-14; 8:1-13).
If you ignore the call of God to a covenant of faith which produces righteousness, then you will live in dead works, walking by the flesh rather than the Spirit. Your works may not even be evil; they’re just “vain and fruitless.”
As Christians we have repented of these dead works and entered into the promises given to Abraham by faith. Speaking of which, I always loved the song “I’m a Covenant Woman.”
The Teaching of Baptisms and the Laying on of Hands
When I was a new Christian, this was a puzzle to me. I had an idea of what this might mean, but the dissension over baptism, baptisms (of water and the Holy Spirit), speaking in languages, and laying on of hands between Baptists and Pentecostals distressed and confused me.
How wonderful it was to find the writing of the apostles’ churches (“early church fathers”) and see their strong emphasis on baptisms, baptism in water and in the Holy Spirit. Three things make me confident that they knew exactly what the writer of Hebrews meant by the teaching of baptisms and the laying on of hands.
- They were too close to apostolic times to have forgotten a “first principle of Christ.”
- There universal practice was to baptize in water (by immersion, but if water was not available, then pouring three times over the head, once each in the name of the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit, e.g., Didache 7), then anointed the baptized person with oil, laying hands on them, and praying for them to be baptized in the Holy Spirit (e.g., Tertullian, “On Baptism,” chs. 6-8).
The teaching of baptisms refers to the baptism in water, where sins are forgiven and the sinner is born again or “regenerated” (John 3:3-5; see also Justin Martyr, “First Apology,” ch. 61), and baptism in the Holy Spirit, wherein the saints are empowered for their new life. The laying on of hands was a part of this (see link in #2 above). These are the baptisms, plural, that all Christians receive. Paul mentions this in his letter to Titus:
… not by works of righteousness which we did ourselves, but according to his mercy, he saved us through the washing of regeneration and renewing by the Holy Spirit (Tit. 3:5)
Note: From experience, I know many will miss my point and tell me, “See, see! We are not saved by works.” I, of course, know this is true. We are transferred from darkness to light, born again, and created in Christ Jesus to do good works by faith and apart from works. We do not, however, inherit God’s kingdom at the judgment by faith, but by works (2 Cor. 5:10; Matt. 25:31-46; cf. Rev. 2-3).
Now, we see in Scripture that laying on of hands was also done to appoint elders (1 Tim. 5:22), impart gifts (1 Tim. 4:14), and send missionaries (Acts 13:3), but this article is about Hebrews 6:1-2 and the “first things of Christ.” Appointing elders is not a “first thing,” nor is sending gifted men into the world.
The “teaching of baptisms and laying on of hands” is a doublet referring to our first salvation, being born again in the baptisms of water and Spirit, the latter done with the laying on of hands. You can see this throughout Acts, but just Acts 19:1-6 makes a fine example.
Note: From experience, I know I will get a lot of pushback on baptism because evangelicals don’t want to believe it has anything to do with being saved. This is despite the fact that baptism is repeatedly said to be for the release of sins and that Galatians 3:27 tells us that baptism is how we put on Christ. Obviously, God has been quite flexible with us, saving many by faith without baptism but baptism, according to Scripture, is supposed to be what we do as an initiation rite into the church. We believer, and therefore we are buried with Christ in baptism and raised with him to new life when we come out of the water. It is a powerful symbol that has been poorly replace by a sinner’s prayer.
The Resurrection of the Dead and Eternal Judgment
The resurrection of the dead is the hope of all Christians. In Romans 8:18-25 the day on which God redeems our bodies is such a glorious day that the whole creation rejoices. In fact, God’s creation waits with eager expectation for that day. For me, it brings to mind a dog’s wagging of both tail and body in its eager expectation of its master’s return. I want to be like that dog in the way I wait for my Master.
We have to qualify for this day, however. Paul describes his great effort to attain to that day in Philippians 3:8-14, then tells us in 8:15 to have the same mind. He does make a promise to us that that day will find us “holy, without defect, and blameless” if we continue grounded and settled in the faith.
I am scared for Americans like you and me, though, that we don’t know what it means to be grounded in the faith. Too many of us feel free to ignore things Jesus taught. For example, how many Christians agree that if we are slapped on one cheek–which implies insulting, not a fist fight–we should turn the other? Mr. T, the famous actor from the 70s and 80s doesn’t. His words to the public were, “I’m a Christian, but I’m not Jesus. If you hit me on one cheek, I’m gonna hit you back.”
Worse, though, is our attitude about riches. It does not look to me like we believe that it is so difficult for a rich man to enter the kingdom of God that it requires a miracle of God. I have never heard a sermon that would help me decide whether a retirement account equates to storing up riches on earth. I’ve almost never heard someone teach that wanting to be rich is a trap that leads to many foolish and harmful lusts. These lusts “drown men in ruin and destruction” (1 Tim. 6:19).
You’d think that in the richest, or almost richest, nation in the world, the New Testament warnings against wealth would be trumpeted and repeated often. Instead, the only one constantly trumpeting publicly about wealth are prosperity preachers teaching the very opposite of those warnings.
It takes generosity to save a rich man (1 Tim. 6:16-19). It is by generosity that a “good foundation” is laid up “against the time to come” (eternal judgment), so that we may “lay hold of for eternal life.”
Doesn’t the wording of that passage sound like Paul’s words in Philippians 3:8-14?
Peter tells all of us, not just the rich, to live in fear of that day throughout “the time of our sojourning here” (1 Peter 1:17). In fact, by saying “If you address as Father the one who impartially judges according to our works,” he is telling us that warning is for Christians alone. The lost don’t necessarily know that there is coming a day when God will judge everyone by one Man (Acts 17:31).
We cannot pick and choose the verses we like as though the Bible were a buffet. We ignore all the verses warning us about eternal judgment (by works) at our peril. We try to brush off Jesus’ warning that one day we Christians along with everyone else will be divided into sheep and goats, differentiated only by their treatment of the needy (Matt. 25:31-46), by calling it a judgment of the nations. Do we really thing the sheep and goats are nations, or that nations do not consist of people?
More amazingly, I have heard Christians, and even pastors, teach that when we stand before the Bema seat of Christ, rather than the Great White Throne judgment of Revelation 20, that only our good works will be judged. I guess they missed the “whether good or bad” at the end of 2 Corinthians 5:10.
The Bible tells us that we are to work out our salvation with fear and trembling (Php. 2:12), but we spend our time on assurance instead. Yes, we are able to work out our salvation because God is at work in us both to desire and to do his will, but let’s not forget Paul’s application of working out our salvation in the very next chapter! (Php. 3:8-15).
I write all the time about the resurrection (of life for the righteous and of condemnation for the wicked–John 5:27-29) and eternal judgment a lot on this blog and on Facebook, and I hope I have said enough here to explain why. If you have questions about what I have written here, I write a lot on Facebook and this blog about resurrection and eternal judgment; I have at least dozens of other verses that I cover on this subject.
Unfortunately, resurrection and eternal judgment is supposed to be a “first thing,” but evangelical tradition has just about erased it from our mind. If you want the short version of how resurrection and eternal judgment work, search the word “if” in the New Testament or just keep your eye out for it as your read your Bible, then read Jesus’ letters to the churches in Revelation 2-3. There Jesus gives us a picture of how he will judge on the last day, judging those 7 churches by their deeds without every mentioning their faith.
On the subject of resurrection and eternal judgment I beg you with the apostles that you do not be deceived.
Or don’t you know that the unrighteous will not inherit God’s Kingdom? Don’t be deceived. Neither the sexually immoral, nor idolaters, nor adulterers, nor male prostitutes, nor homosexuals, nor thieves, nor covetous, nor drunkards, nor slanderers, nor extortionists, will inherit God’s Kingdom. Some of you were such, but you were washed. But you were sanctified. But you were justified in the name of the Lord Jesus, and in the Spirit of our God. (1 Corinthians 6:9-11)
Know this for sure, that no sexually immoral person, nor unclean person, nor covetous man, who is an idolater, has any inheritance in the Kingdom of Christ and God. Let no one deceive you with empty words. For because of these things, the wrath of God comes on the children of disobedience. (Eph. 5:5-6)
Little children, let no one lead you astray. He who does righteousness is righteous, even as he is righteous. (1 Jn. 3:7)
There are a lot of opinions and rumors about Constantine, the Council of Nicea, and the events of the fourth century that changed Christianity to Christendom. Not only will you get the incredible story, with all its twists, plots, and intrigues, but you will find out how history is done and never wonder what is true again.
Hi Jon,
I’ve wrestled with all these thoughts, though nowadays it is mostly in regard to how people perceive what I write. The people I am thinking of when I write a post affect the article. In this case I was thinking of very diligent people who are trying to build an overall model (as in scientific model) of the whole message of the Bible.
Nonetheless, when I walk away, I think of how to reach the average American Christian who sits in a pew, avoids adultery and murder, and is basically coasting along with the rest of the church attenders. They don’t know, internally, that God hates divorce and considers at least some remarriages adultery.
That said, I think you’ll find my next post to be another time when I am writing a post in answer to your comment but, in this case, it’s not. The heart of the post is already formed in my mind.
Nowadays, I’m in the habit of combining the elementary principle of eternal judgment with an even more elementary principle of God’s abundant and prodigious mercy. It’s easy to hear in my teaching a call for sinless perfection despite the fact that I know that anyone who claims sinless perfection is blind. They are blind to themselves, blind to the gifts of God, and blind to the humility that the Holy Spirit imparts to us.
I always hope that people pick up on the simplicity of “if you continue in the faith, grounded and settled therein,” but I know most don’t. Worse, yesterday, I undercut that verse with the truth that most American Christians have little understanding of the faith, thinking that the faith is “Don’t smoke, cuss, or chew, nor hang out with those that do,” but we can still pursue riches, divorce and remarry, and consider the American dream a righteous dream.
How to cover the mercy of God with the demands of God, the command of God for all people everywhere to repent? That is a question I live with constantly. The things I wrote yesterday are true; they’re only not true if it makes you picture the God you described, rather than the one that can be approached in the way Kathy Troccoli sings in “Stubborn Love”:
Caught again, Your faithless friend
Don’t You ever tire of hearing what a fool I’ve been?
Guess I should pray, but what can I say?
Oh, it hurts to know the hundred times I’ve caused You pain
Though “Forgive me” sounds so empty when I never change
Yet You stay and say, “I love you still”
Forgiving me time and time again
That’s a real experience I have had and occasionally have, as do many, many others. That is expressed best, in my opinion, in 1 John 1:7-2:2, but my favorite verse about God’s mercy is the abundant pardon of Isaiah 55:7, with Exodus 34:6-7 a close second.
Thanks Paul
I really appreciate these little exchanges, even when I can push quite hard.
You said “How to cover the mercy of God with the demands of God, the command of God for all people everywhere to repent? That is a question I live with constantly.”
Indeed, this is the question that I wrestle with and I want to be able to hold both sides together without diminishing either. I have found it striking how I see both of these aspects side by side in the scripture. I suppose it’s the theological equivalent of trying to look at two things at once without just focusing on one.
I find it interesting some of the issues that you mentioned that you say American evangelicals ignore. I personally have agonised over the finance/stewardship question, often thinking having conversations with my wife along the lines of “are we giving enough away? how much is a sensible amount to spend on a holiday (vacation)? etc) It again comes down to squaring up the warnings about wealth with “God loves a cheerful giver” 2 Cor2 9:7. The whole saving for retirement issue is a little different where I am as we have a pension system that is fairly automatic (i.e. an amount gets deducted from my salary and put into a pension before it ever reaches me).
I look forward to reading your next post on mercy that you mentioned is upcoming.
I have actually been very slowly working on a talk/script that goes over some of these issues in the light of scripture and attempts to reach some conclusions. My eventual aim is to turn it into a YouTube video (I’ll send it you when/if it is completed!)
Thanks
Jon
Do send that to me! And here’s that promised post: https://ancient-faith.com/2024/12/09/gods-stubborn-love-and-abundant-pardon/
Hi Paul
Thank you for your recent posts. I am cautious about simply treading over ground with you that we have already covered over the years, though naturally there are going to be recurring themes.
Perhaps unsurprisingly, I found myself unable to stomach your last point about judgment (or rather how you expand the point in Hebrews). I do so for scriptural reasons but also because of the implications and how, frankly, impossible I find it to hold these ideas in tension with a God who is supposed to love us and want to save his beloved children who were bought at a great price.
Scriptures
While I don’t agree with or hold to what is sometimes called the “Free Grace” position on this as a whole, I believe there are some scriptures that DO refer to a judgement for believers where rewards and chastisement are in view, NOT eternal condemnation. 1 Cor 3:12-15 is a clear example of this. I would also argue that 2 Cor 5:10 is actually unclear as to what element of the judgment is in view (it says nothing about final destination) and could be referring to something similar.
You mentioned 1 Tim 6:19 as referring to final judgment too, but I cannot see that it is obvious from the text that “good foundation” and “laying hold of truly life” refer to final judgement and seems to be, frankly, reading this into the text. If you are correct, it is almost implying that we buy our salvation by giving away money (or are robbed of it at divine gun point in my opinion).
In 1 Thess 4:13-18, Paul offers comfort and encouragement regarding those who have died, saying “For we believe that Jesus died and rose again, and so we believe that God will bring with Jesus those who have fallen asleep in him.” He didn’t see it necessary to add “providing they have been good enough, done enough works and given enough money away, or providing they pass the judgement”.
Similarly, if you are correct, it does seem like the thief on cross in Luke 23 entered eternal life far easier than most people. He had absolutely nothing to lose as he was dying anyway, and cast himself on Christ’s mercy. Indeed, there seems to have been a practice in the early centuries of delaying baptism until near death due to a belief that post-baptismal sins were very hard for God to forgive, like God is only really forgiving once (rather than “70×7).
Finally, the way you speak about judgement day implies that there is a certain amount of unknowing before that time, where we await the final verdict. However, scripture seems clear that upon death people immediately go to a good place or a bad place, and the judgement comes at the end of the age (I forget the exact references here but I think you’d agree).
Implications
I am fully aware that the fear of the Lord is the beginning of wisdom (Prov 9:10) and that this is a neglected truth.
However, what I struggle with on a daily basis is what I can only describe as a background dread of God – that he might actually hate me, that my faith might be a sham, that he is mad at him for not loving him enough, that my lack of spiritual experiences might be indications that his back is turned to me. I try to fight these thoughts with the promises of scripture (e.g. John 6:37, Matt 11:28-29 etc), but I cannot seem to shake a thought at the back of my mind that I might be going to hell.
Let me just spell out that last point – I think we can agree that hell is the absolute worst thing that could happen to anyone, worse than losing a child, getting cancer, nuclear war or anything else (even if it does result in eventual annihilation, which I think you believe). . Yet, that’s what I live in daily dread of. I recently confessed this to a much older wiser saint (who is one of the most virtuous and loving people I know) and he was so shocked that’s how I lived that he welled up with tears.
Is this how we are supposed to live each day? That God who did not spare his own son and who has promised give us all things (Rom 8:32), nevertheless holds a divine gun to the heads of his OWN CHILDREN, and effectively says “Be perfect OR ELSE, do good works OR ELSE, don’t you DARE save for retirement OR ELSE” etc.
Matt 7:13-14 is a serious scripture that needs to be reckoned with, but I can’t help thinking that if God has deliberately made the way so, so narrow that so few are saved then does he really want to save many people? Is he actually that good at saving?
It is for this reason that I really struggle to love Christ from the heart, though I pray to be able to every day. Is this really surprising though? If an earthly father acted how you have described (i.e. endless threats of final punishment) could you blame his child for not feeling love for him?
I should finish with a disclaimer of sorts. Despite saying all the above, I cling to Christ as best as I can each day, and read scripture every day with a strong focus on the gospels (currently in Matthew). When I come across command I ponder what obedience to it might look like in my life, and pray for strength to obey. I take warnings seriously too, but these days try not to dwell on them too much as it usually ends up leading to turning things over and over without resolution. I also pray, regarding the kind of thoughts I’ve expressed here, for forgiveness if they are blasphemous, and ask God to show me his truth and give me his joy (the latter I occasionally experience flickers of when reading scripture).
It’s been a while Paul and I apologise for the rant, but these questions still play on my mind every day.
Jon